Hi
Note: You can add "Shake" as an effect in itself. Unclick it in "Old film" effect pane and add "Shake" as a separate effect.
If you don't want black and white you could also add the "Sepia" effect but it's no substitute to having a coloured "old film" clip.
The nearest you can get currently to what you require is....
Place the clip on Video Track 1 and also on Video track 2. LIne them up. Video track 2 is the overlay track and for a start is the only one you will see if the sequence is played.
Now add your "Old Film" effect to Video Track 1.
Add the "Transparency" effect to Video track 2
The default Transparency (Opacity) is 50% so when the sequence is now played you will see your "Old" film in black and white through the normal coloured clip on Track 2.
You should be able to adjust the transparency (opacity) so the sequence looks like an old coloured clip. Try about 60% opacity for a start. The higher the value the more colour and the less "Old film" effect.
Nat